MORAL DILEMAS
Write three paragraphs about Matt’s dilemma in the Photo Story on page 111.
In the first paragraph, summarize the situation. In the
second paragraph, write about what Matt could
or should do. In the third paragraph, write what you would do if you were Matt. Explain your reasons, using the unreal
conditional.
SHEYLA REASCOS CALDERON
ResponderBorrarThe characters talk about one of them picking up a plate and it broke in his hands, the friend tells him that maybe it was already broken and not to worry because Matt was very scared because it would cost him a lot of money, his friend told him to leave it there because no one saw it and Matt says no because he puts himself in the owner's place and that he would not like someone to do the same, he replies that for the owner that is very little but for you it will cost you a lot of money, Matt replies that if he did that he would not feel good about it.
Matt should do is notify the owner of the store and then tell what happened and if it is the case, reach a payment agreement and for both of them it will look good on both sides, I think that would be the right thing to do.
I would tell the owner what happened and then I would tell him how things happened and if I didn't have money I would agree to a payment agreement, because it wouldn't be right if I left something broken there and pretend that nothing happened.
In the
LÓPEZ ROSERO MARJORIE LIZETH
ResponderBorrarMatt is having a moral dilemma on his work, probably he don´t wait that in the kitchen he have to found a broken plate, he´s having a debate about what they have to do with this situation, Noah has said that the don´t have to talk about that and just split of the situation. Mat think that he have to communicate the situation with his boss and assume the consequences because it´s the correct, he thinks that if he been the owner he likes to know about similar situations.
Matt could go until his boss office’s to talk a try to solute the situation, or first able he should to try to talk with the kitchen´s people to know what is the true. He should to review the security cameras to check what happened with the plate, probably just was an error and could to reopen that. He should to check who was designed to serve that table and these food and he could intuitive who was the responsible.
If he talked about the problem he could get an askance for his responsibility, but probably if he did that their colleges could been furious, because anybody do that. If he found the responsible he could try to talk and repair the damage without talk with their boss, if he thoughts to avoid the problem he couldn’t face himself. If he does the correct he could feel a better person and correct, he should to try to discover the real facts and be responsible with the information
William Andrés Armas Medina
ResponderBorrarMatt and his friend Noah went to a store and while they were looking at the items there, there was an accident and Matt broke a plate that is very expensive and has a dilemma because his friend tells him that he should leave it there and go out without notify, but his conscience does not allow it and he thinks he should tell the owner of the store and pay but it is very expensive.
He should tell the truth to the owners of the store so that they are aware of what happened because that way they could reach an agreement on its price since it is an expensive item that was an accident and so he could pay for the broken item without any problem.
If I were Matt I would tell my friend Noah that what he tells me to do isn´t the right thing to do and then I would go to the owner of the store and I would tell him about the accident that happened to me so that we can reach an agreement and have him tell me what you should pay with a reasonable price and so we could both be calm doing things in the best way.
In reading page 111 you can clearly see that Matt is having a moral dilemma in his work, possibly he does not expect that in the kitchen he will have to find a broken plate, Matt is having a debate about the situation they are still going through. Mat considers that he should quickly communicate to his leader what is happening in the kitchen and should accept the consequences and responsibilities of his actions as this would be convenient, Matt supposes that if he were the owner of the restaurant he would like to know everything that happens there inside.
ResponderBorrarMatt could talk with his leader about the case that is being experienced, he could also try to communicate with the kitchen staff to reach a conclusion. And last but not least, you must find out or consult who has been the one who attended said message to offer with the person in charge.
If he was responsible, he could try to speak and compose the evil without this reaching the highest instances, he must face his inconveniences head-on because that will help him to do things in a better way. I think that if you do things in a good way and giving your best, you can find out who has actually been responsible for this problem.
In this story we are told that Matt accidentally broke a plate. Then his friend Noah tells him that it is possible that he was already broken and not to worry. Matt was worried that it would cost him a lot of money. However, Noah advises her to leave it there because no one saw it. But Matt says that he refuses to leave it there, because he was performing an act of empathy towards the owner. Noah replies that for the owner that is very little money, so don't worry.
ResponderBorrarMatt should notify the store owner of what happened, they could work out a payment arrangement, so he would feel better about doing the right thing.
In my case, he would let the owner know and probably help me pay it off in installments or maybe the owner forgets about the debt and it's my reward for being honest.
Jhoseline Leticia Cordova Pineda
ResponderBorrar- Matt, is a person of good values, who saw that if he has already made a mistake he wants to do things right, he broke a plate and wants to tell the owner so they have to discount it, while Noah wants to convince him not to tell him nothing and pretend nothing happened, he wants him to hide the plate and not tell the owner, but Matt refuses to follow his advice.
- It is correct that Matt talk to the owner and explain what happened, that would be a good sign of Matt's personality that is honest and even if he does things wrong he wants to tell the truth even if he has to lose.
- If I were Matt, what I would do would be to tell the owner not to hide it, putting myself in his shoes and for better or for the better, I would love for them to always tell me the truth, and what I would do would be to explain to Noah that you have to know how to face things and not hide it no matter how badly it has done him, knowing how to face and tell the truth.
1. Matt and Noah enter a store and Matt is looking at the plates and finds one that is broken, he tells Noah that he can't believe what he finds, but Noah tells him not to worry that maybe the plate could already be there broken and nobody noticed, Noah tells him that it is better to leave the plate where it was so as not to have problems with the owner and not pay for something that they did not do, but Matt says that it is better to tell the owner that he has met him broken plate.
ResponderBorrar2. Matt should tell the owner of the place that he found the broken plate and explain that he did not break it and the evidence is in the security cameras, which the owner could believe Matt.
Matt could walk away without saying anything and leave the plate as it was because he might not be believed by the owner but it would be best to be honest and tell the owner.
3. If I found a broken plate, I would tell the owner of the place that I found the plate this broken and he can see on the security cameras that I found it this way.
If I were the owner of the place, I would like them to tell me that they found a broken plate, we would talk and I would understand that they didn't break it.
Carlos Vásquez
ResponderBorraras first we can see that matt has a plate in his hands which his friend Noah broke it tells him to leave it there and pretend nothing has happened, but on the other hand matt says that he could not live with the weight of doing that to the owner and to notify him so that they can reach an agreement.
what matt should do is call the owner of the plate and explain that it was an accident and that they reach a mutual agreement
What I would do is what was already mentioned before, talk to the owner, tell him that it was an accident and reach an agreement if I don't have money, pay him with work.
FUERTES GRACE
ResponderBorrarFirst paragraph:
It is a situation between two friends who are Matt and Noe, it happened that Matt accidentally broke one of the local dishes in his hands, which are very expensive and Matt could not afford it, although his friend Noe tells him that maybe it already came broken.
Second paragraph:
Given the situation that is found, it would be most likely that Matt would not take care of the dish and make any excuse that it was already broken in the package and it was not his fault, and not take care of it because the prices are very expensive.
On the other hand Matt thinks to do the right thing, to tell the owner of the plates what happened and assume his responsibility whether or not it was with the intention that the plate was broken.
If he tells the truth and is honest with the boss, he wouldn't have so many problems with the owner. But if he doesn't say what happened, he would have trouble paying for the plate.
Third paragraph:
If I were Matt, I would tell the truth about what happened to the plate.
Although it may not have been my direct fault, it broke in my hands and therefore it is my responsibility.
If I have to assume my position with responsibility, I would not have problems with the boss of the place.
If I had to pay for the broken dish, I wouldn't have any more worries.
In the images a little story is told about two friends who are in a store in the porcelain utensils aisle, at that moment Matt apparently by accident breaks one of the dishes and is very worried about the consequences of having to pay a lot for the damage; but Noah who is the other friend tells him to do as if nothing and leave the dish without telling anyone; however Matt mentions that he does not think it is right because he puts himself in the place of the owner and does not think the situation is fair.
ResponderBorrarMatt should inform the store manager about the accident, explain that it was not his intention and try to reach an agreement so that no one is harmed. In this way Matt would be an honest and responsible person with his actions.
I, would tell the store manager what has happened and assume my mistake since it was an accident; then I would try to reach an agreement to pay for the dish and not harm anyone; since I consider that would be the right thing to do and an act of honesty and respect.
LORENA LIZBETH POZO AGUINAGA
ResponderBorrar1. Matt found a broken plate in a store and he wants to tell the man but his friend tells him that it is not necessary but he tries to do the right thing and that he could not leave the place without telling the owner about what is happening because he does not know would feel good.
2. The best thing I could do is tell the man because it would be a noble and fair act because the owner does not know what is happening and leaving a broken plate in the premises would not be right and it would be good to tell the man so that he can place a plate that is not broken.
3. What I would do would be to tell the owner because it would be the right thing to do because later the store owner will think that I broke the plate when that didn't really happen so the best option is to tell him why so the store owner could replace the broken plate for a new and better one and thus there would be no misunderstandings.
Iván Steven Vallejo
ResponderBorrar1: The characters talk about one of them picking up a broken plate, his friend says that maybe it was already broken and not to worry, matt was the one who was worried because it would cost him a lot of money, his friend told him not to worry, to leave where he was no one saw it and Matt says no because he wouldn't want someone to do the same thing, Matt replies that if he did he wouldn't feel good about it.
2:
What Matt should do is notify the owner of the store and then tell him what happened and say that he found a broken plate to reach a solution for both and that the two are not so affected.
3:
I would tell the owner what happened and then I would tell him how things happened and I would explain that maybe that plate was already broken and if I didn't have money I would agree to settle because it wouldn't be right to leave something broken but I wouldn't blame myself either. something that was broken before, so it would be best to agree on both sides.
DARLY YAYNELA ALMEIDA CASTRO
ResponderBorrar-Matt literally took a plate that was broken in 2 of the shelf where he works to admire it because it caught his attention, his friend Noah tells him to calm down, that probably that plate was already broken, only that it was hidden, but Matt can not calm down because the price of that dish is very expensive and will cost him an eye of the face.
-Matt, you should tell the owner that you broke the plate because it's the right thing to do.
-If I were Matt, I wouldn't tell the owner, because he would practically get angry and charge a very expensive price for it.
Mat and his friend visit a luxurious store, they were curious to see all the things that were in that place, Mat takes a plate that is on top and realizes that it was broken in two. Mat warns his friend of the situation and he gets scared because he said it was going to cost him a foot and an arm because of the high prices that the store handled, his friend told him to leave it like that and not say anything but Matt couldn't handle all that.
ResponderBorrarMatt should notify the store owner of the situation, tell the truth about him saying that when he took it it was broken, it was not his fault because that was already the case.
If I were Matt I would always tell the truth what happened, it wasn't my fault that it was already like that and if you don't believe me then I would have to pay for it, but I would reach an agreement with the owner of the place so that he doesn't charge me much at least fifty percent less or try to fix the situation.
Nathaly Chiluisa
ANTHONY ARMAS
ResponderBorrarIn the dilemma that Matt and Noah find themselves in, it is because an expensive plate from a store was broken due to this situation. Noah's friend proposes that he leave there and leave the place, but Matt tells him that this is not right that he has to face the problem and pay the owner even if this is expensive.
think that Matt could talk to the owner of the store to explain the inconvenience that happened with this dish and the situation may arise that the owner understands that it was something that happened due to bad luck and does not charge him so much for this problem.
If I find myself in Matt's place, I would accept my mistake and I would prefer to explain the truth of what happened to the owner of the store because he has an investment in his business that helps him survive and I would hope that the owner understood the situation to reach an agreement.
1.-Matt is working in a store with his friend Noah, Matt had an unexpected accident when taking a plate to look at it, the plate broke and Matt does not have enough money to pay for it, which his friend Noah advises him not to say anything to. owner, since he has a lot of money to replace it and for him it would be just a drop in the ocean. Matt is not very convinced to remain silent since for him that is not the right thing to do, but his economic state makes him do the wrong thing.
ResponderBorrar2.-What Matt should do is not be influenced by his friend Noah and do what his heart tells him so that he can be calm and at peace with himself. That is, so that Matt does not feel guilty, he should have warned the owner and assumed the consequences even if it was not his fault, perhaps the owner listening to Matt's version could have believed him and helped him in a certain way.
3.-If I were Matt and I would not have financial stability, I would not say anything to the owner and I would leave. Because the plate was probably already broken and if I tell the owner he can take decisions against me.
Edison Xavier Mina Garcia
ResponderBorrarMatt and Noah are workers at a fine crockery shop. While Matt is cleaning, he finds two broken plates and tells his roommate that he would rather throw them out before the owner finds out. But Noah would like to tell the owner. They then begin to discuss what is the best thing to do.
When Matt finds the broken dishes, he has to tell the owner because it wasn't his fault, but if he broke them he would rather hide them so as not to pay. Since Noah was present, he asked for an opinion on what he should do with the dishes.
If so, that would be my case. He would tell the owner what happened because it wasn't my fault and it would keep me out of trouble. I would not move the plates for my partner to be a witness and I would call the owner to see how the plates were.
Este comentario ha sido eliminado por el autor.
ResponderBorrarSteve Mejía
ResponderBorrarIn the story, you can see Matt and Noah who went shopping and looking for a plate, one of them was broken in Matt's hands and it was probably very expensive, the situation is that, Noah tells him to leave it where it is. found so that no one would notice, but Matt says that he should report what happened to the owner because it would be a loss and he would not like to be in his shoes and someone break such an expensive plate.
The right thing is for Matt to report what happened to a manager, perhaps it was already broken and the employees give him a solution and he does not remain guilty of conscience, since if he leaves it there there are two options, that the owners of the store they discover him and get into a serious problem or that he is not calm all day with what happened
If I were in Matt's place, I would report it to the store, he had the cameras checked to avoid misunderstandings and explain what happened, and if they found me guilty, I would cover the costs and take the piece, it can be of some use, but I would exhaust all the resources so that I don't have problems.
Alondra Méndez
ResponderBorrarFirst paragraph
It is a situation that has happened to Matt through no fault of his own. Matt picks up a plate to look at it and breaks it, realizing the price is too high. Noah tells him to go back to the shelf that no one saw. Matt tells him that he couldn't do that and that he put himself in the owner's place. Noah tells him that for him it would be a lot of money and for the owner it is nothing. Matt comments that if he runs away he won't be able to face himself.
Second paragraph
What Matt could do is tell the owner that he only took the plate to look at it and it broke, that he did not force it, much less did it fall, to check the cameras or what he can do because the plate is expensive, or take responsibility and pay . And let it stay as a warning that nothing should be found.
Third Paragraph
If I were Matt and I'm sure I didn't break the plate I would tell the owner that I only took the plate to look at it and it broke and if I have to pay because it broke in my hands I have to take the consequences and not hit anything again and much less if it is a very expensive item.
Matt is in a shop with his friend Noah, Matt tells his friend that the things sold here are too expensive because they have ridiculous prices, then a plate Matt had in his hands breaks, and Noah tells him to leave it there as no one saw it and the prices are too high to pay, Matt feels upset because he doesn't want to leave the plate as he puts himself in the owner's shoes and thinks he would like to be told if something breaks. Noah insists that he leave the plate in place but Matt decides not to because it wouldn't be okay.
ResponderBorrarMatt seeing himself in that situation could simply leave the plate in place and leave as no one saw it but this is not correct as he broke something that is not his, but the right thing is for Matt to accept what he did and tell the owner so that the owner can decide what to do in these cases, therefore, the right thing to do is for Matt to say what happened since this is an act of honesty.
If I were Matt I would feel scared because something that is not mine broke in my hands, but the right thing to do is to communicate what happened by telling the truth, this is why what I would do is go to the person in charge or the owner to discuss the situation and let him decide what will be done.
Bryan Hemiro Tugumbango Siza
ResponderBorrarIn this situation Matt and Noah enter a store to buy. In this case Matt looks at the plates and notices that one of them is broken. Realizing this Noah tells him not to worry that maybe the plate could have already been broken and no one noticed until Matt took it. Immediately Noah tells him that it is better to leave the plate right there to avoid problems with the owner and avoid paying for a broken plate. Matt answers him and tells him: that it would be better to tell the owner that he has found a broken plate and thus not have problems. They argue to the end and Matt decides to face the situation.
What Matt could do in this situation is obey Noah. Because if he doesn't believe them, the owner is going to charge them for something that Matt didn't do, and this wouldn't be fair to him. On the other hand, what he should do is tell the owner that there is a plate that is broken and nobody has noticed and that he only came to look at the plates and he didn't even take it if he wanted to.
If I were in Matt's situation. I would report to the store owner that there is a broken plate. He would explain to him that I went to look at the plates and when he was going to take it, the plate was already broken. In this case, if the owner does not believe me, he would ask him to check a security camera to prove my sincerity and verify that I am not lying to him.
Estévez Palacios Sebastián Gustavo
ResponderBorrarIn the first picture you can see that matt was looking at the super high prices of each one of the objects and when he took one of them it broke in two when he realized its price he said that it was going to be very expensive, while his friend Noah told him to be calm that maybe there was a chance that it had already been broken.
2.- What matt should do is ask the owner of the store to check each object as they can be of very poor quality and that is why they break so easily, since by wanting to leave the plate broken matt would be the accomplice, in which he is totally innocent and he was just watching with his friend.
3.- What I would have done is to talk to the owner and give him an explanation of what happened, since leaving the broken plate there would be very rude and not the right thing to do. And I would be giving myself as guilty for having left the broken plate in its place.
Write three paragraphs about Matt's dilemma in the photo story on page 111.
ResponderBorrarNoah and Matt find themselves in a moral dilemma when they observe that Matt took a plate and when he took it it broke in two, the two were scared to learn that the plate has a high price. Noah tries to calm the moment saying that maybe the plate has already been broken, wanting to convince Matt to leave the plate because there is no one to see them and leave the store. But Matt tries to get Noah to put himself in the shoes of the store owner who wouldn't want them to do that to him.
Matt should call a store manager informing that they found a broken plate and look for the solution, either by proving by the security cameras that Matt did not break the plate.
If I were Matt, I would tell a manager that I found the broken plate and if there is a problem anyway, I would pay for the broken plate.
When Matt and his friend Noah went to a store, to discover that his friend broke a plate that was in that place, and that plate was very expensive for which he found himself in a moral dilemma, because his friend told him to leave without notify what happened, but in his mind he thought that he should notify the manager and solve the problem.
ResponderBorrarMatt should be honest and honest, he should tell the manager what happened and try to solve the problem, because if nobody takes care of the broken plate, it is possible that someone else will be blamed.
The most advisable thing is always to look for the solution to the problems, I would talk to the person in charge to see how we can pay for the broken plate and that nobody has problems later, I would talk to my friend and make him see that he made a mistake and he should pay for it, I would also talk to the manager and I would tell him to check the security cameras and see that it was an unforeseen act and no one had the real intention of damaging something.
Joseph Perugachi
ResponderBorrarMatt is having a moral dilemma on his work, probably he don´t wait that in the kitchen he have to found a broken plate, he´s having a debate about what they have to do with this situation, Noah has said that the don´t have to talk about that and just split of the situation. Mat think that he have to communicate the situation with his boss and assume the consequences because it´s the correct, he thinks that if he been the owner he likes to know about similar situations.
Matt could go until his boss office’s to talk a try to solute the situation, or first able he should to try to talk with the kitchen´s people to know what is the true. He should to review the security cameras to check what happened with the plate, probably just was an error and could to reopen that. He should to check who was designed to serve that table and these food and he could intuitive who was the responsible.
If he talked about the problem he could get an askance for his responsibility, but probably if he did that their colleges could been furious, because anybody do that. If he found the responsible he could try to talk and repair the damage without talk with their boss, if he thoughts to avoid the problem he couldn’t face himself. If he does the correct he could feel a better person and correct, he should to try to discover the real facts and be responsible with the information.
Karol Stefany Morillo Criollo
ResponderBorrarThe dilemma is about two friends who are in a crockery store, Matt is watching and picks up a plate and when he has it in his hands it breaks, he gets scared and tells his friend he tells him that he should leave it there and go as if nothing happened It would have happened, but Matt tells him no because he wouldn't feel good doing that, it was better to tell the owner and reach an agreement.
I think that if Matt broke the plate he could tell the truth to the owner and he could check cameras to see if the plate was like that or not and after that being the case that if Matt had broken they could fix it in the way that both of them result.
If that happened to me, what I would do is notify the owner and explain everything and if I had to pay for something I did, I would do it because honesty is better.
PERUGACHI DE LA TORRE KURI.
ResponderBorrarIn the photography story, he narrates a situation of honesty in which two friends entered a store and Matt picks up a plate and realizes that it is broken and he does not know what to do. His friend Noah advises him to put it in the same place. and to keep quiet however Matt does not agree because he is honest and thinks about telling the truth to the owner because he claims that he could not do what Noah tells him.
Matt would try to hide the plate and not tell the owner, however, the right thing would be for Matt and his friend to tell the owner about the situation and tell the truth no matter what it costs them, they should do the right thing by showing that they have values of honesty and kindness.
In my opinion, if I were Matt, I would try to inform the owner of the store and explain what happened and accept the owner's decision because the truth always comes out and the one who does things right brings good things.
Mad and his friend were to the shopping and suddenly matt broke a expensive plate, but his friend tells him no to worry beacuase the plate may have been broken before he took it. Scared mat want to tells the owner what happened, but his friend explains to him that it cannot seem very costly to the owner and that it is better if they leave without saying anything.
ResponderBorrarMat could notify at receptión before leaving the store, and he want to tell the truth at the owner
I think like the matt frinend's because if you pick up anithing for ten seconds an it is broken that's because someone broke it first, so i tell the owner, but a don't pay about it.
Ashley Massiel Mancero Salcedo
ResponderBorrar1.- This situation is that they are sell some products but to someone broke a piece but anyone recognize this problem, Matt can´t believe it because he saw a broken thing in two and the price is very ridiculous but he try to want to solve the problem in the best way , also Matt and Noah are discussing and they don’t looking for a solution to the problem.
2.-Matt should say what really happen with this piece and he try to calm down and he should think things through to salve that problem and not get into an argumrnt , Matt and Noah have to look for a good solution to this problem in a calm way without discuss or angry
3.- If I was Matt , I would have split with Noah and pay together the price of the broken piece, already it was very expensive and we have to be seal people and try o avoid problems and it,s better to fix things and reach a positive agreement and they are with mind and heart in peace because we have to do good actions in the life
Este comentario ha sido eliminado por el autor.
ResponderBorrarMy name is Mireya Dorado
ResponderBorrar1. It is established in the first scene Matt and Noah are waiters in a restaurant, which Matt takes a plate to look at it and it broke in two, he tells Noah that he can not believe what he finds, but Noah tells him not to worry that maybe the plate could already be there broken and nobody noticed, Noah tells him that it is better to leave the plate where it was so as not to have problems with the owner and not pay for something he didn't do, but Matt says that it is better to tell the owner who found him broken plate.
2. In this second dilemma there are two perspectives, one of which is that Matt most likely doesn't care about the broken plate and makes some excuse that it was already broken in the box and it wasn't his fault.
Another situation is, Matt must do the right thing and put into practice the value of honesty, tell the owner what happened that the plate broke in his hands, take responsibility for him if he did it on purpose or not. Telling the truth is the fairest thing for his boss and thus he will not have problems with the owner of the restaurant, otherwise he must assume the consequences of not being honest.
3. Third situation:
If I were Matt, I would practice the value of honesty and loyalty for those who have helped at work, that is, return how gratifying the owner of the restaurant has been to his boss, I would tell him the truth what happened to the dish even if it was not My fault directly, it broke in my hands and therefore it is my responsibility. If I have to assume full responsibility, I would pay what the dish costs and thus I would not have problems in my work and I would feel calmer. I would work with efficiency and full responsibility in my job.
ResponderBorrarMatt and Noah are in a store, Matt tells Noah that a plate is broken and that it is surely very expensive. Your friend suggests leaving it in the same place before anyone notices. At first Matt says his friend is right because the prices are ridiculous and he can't afford that much money. Then Matt reflects and believes that the right thing to do is to notify the owner. Noah tells him that for the owner that must be insignificant because he sure has a lot of money. Matt is determined to say what happened because he believes that is the right thing to do, if he doesn't he will feel very bad and could not blame.
Matt must say what happened to the owner, the truth is the best way, if he tells how the situation happened and apologizes the dream probably understands. Matt must act according to his values, honesty is a value that he must put into practice so that later he does not feel bad and can not be calm.
If I were Matt I would have been very scared too, but I would tell the owner that it was an accident and I promised to pay whatever it cost but asking the owner to be patient with me because if it is very expensive I probably won't be able to pay it right away.
MARITZA CARLOSAMA
ResponderBorrarThis is a story about two friends: Matt and Noha who were visiting a store of very expensive objects, Matt decides to take a plate which breaks when he takes it, he asks Noha what they should do and he tells her that they are too expensive to pay for them that they better leave it there and go, but Matt decides to look for the owner and tell him that he broke it and he is going to pay for it since he couldn´t face hisself , if he does not do the right thing.
Matt was in a dilemma as he could either hide the broken plate and leave with his friend since only he knew what happened to the plate or find the store owner and pay for the plate. Both situations could go through his head however in order for him to feel good about himself he had to do the right thing which was to find the store owner or manager and pay for the dish to feel he did the right thing.
If I had been Matt I would have sought out the owner immediately to pay for the dish that broke on me. I would have done that because it was the right thing to do and because I'm a terrible liar and very nervous about getting yelled at or taken to jail for something like that scares me a lot, so if I were Matt, I would have done that.
Alex Chasiluisa
ResponderBorrar-Matt and Noah were in a store looking at some objects, Matt unintentionally breaks a dish that was extremely expensive. His friend Noah tells him to leave the place without saying anything, that a broken plate would be nothing to the owner, but Matt's conscience would not leave him alone so he did the right thing and stayed.
-Matt could have gone to management and verified if it was indeed already broken or if he broke it, in case Matt had broken the dish, come to an agreement with the owner and settle the payment.
-I would go to the person in charge of the store and explain the situation to see what solution they could give him, since as a doubt remains if it was already broken or not.
Camila Arciniega
ResponderBorrarThe story tells us about the moral dilemma of two friends who were in a warehouse, one of them named Matt only took a plate to look at it and broke right away, so his friend named Noah tells him that since no one saw them he left the dish again on the shelf and leave the place, but Matt said he can't do that because he would not feel good about it when he did not face the situation and with the owner of the place assuming how he would feel if something like this happened.
What he should do is that if Matt broke the plate, he would tell the owner of the place what really happened, because he almost didn't even touch it and the plate broke. Maybe the owner will notice in the recordings of the security camera and will notice the situation. What Matt shouldn't do is listen to the friend who wanted to run out of the place without facing the situation.
If I were in that situation, I would tell the owner of the place what really happened and I would pay for the damage to the dish if necessary. And if I were the owner of the place I would like to find more people who know how to face the consequences of some situation
Matt is in a dilemma about what happened that he broke a plate and he doesn't know whether to tell his boss on the other hand Noah tells him to ignore the situation, but Matt is convinced that he should tell his boss about what happened.
ResponderBorrarMatt should tell the truth and tell his boss about the situation so they could work out a pay deal, so he would feel better about doing the right thing.
In my case, I would tell him the truth about the dish and what happened so that I could reach an agreement and see how I could pay if he discounted my monthly payments or if he would forgive me because in the end it was an accident.
Matt and his friend Noah went to a pottery store, and when they were browsing through the shelves Matt picked up a plate to look at it and noticed that the plate was broken in two pieces, and when he told his friend Noah what happened he told him to leave the plate on the shelf and run away from the place, however, Matt felt that this was not the right action to take, Matt felt that this was not the right action to take, so he thought that he should put himself in the owner's shoes and it would be fair that the person who breaks a plate should be responsible and pay what the plate cost and so it was, even though the price of the ceramic plate was high, it was fair that as he broke it, he should pay for it.
ResponderBorrarMatt probably paid for the ceramic plate that was broken, because he didn't think it was fair to run away from the place leaving the plate there, even if his friend thinks otherwise. He thought about how the owner would feel, and thought that if he ran away from the place leaving the plate there his conscience would not be clear, instead if he took care of the plate, even if it cost him an arm and a leg, but he would feel at ease with his conscience.
If I were Matt I would explain to the owner of the ceramic store how it happened, because surely the plate already had a crack, but when I took it it broke in two and we know that ceramic is a very resistant material except for bumps and falls. Then I would notify the owner of what happened and if he thinks I am lying, I would pay him the value of the ceramic plate.
Matt and Noah they were in a ceramic plate store. Matt just picked up a plate from the look, but it was broken. He thinks he broke the plate. The ceramic plate is very expensive and Matt didn’t have money. His friend Noha tells him that maybe the plate was broken and Matt didn't realize. Noha believe that is better say nothing and go home. But Matt think that is better pay the plate broke.
ResponderBorrarMatt should talk to the owner of the strore and tell him the truth. The owner can know if the plate is broken or not, and thus tell him if he pays or not. Matt should tell the truth and pay for the plate, the advice that his friend Noah is bad and without values.
I would tell the owner what happened and then I would tell him how things happened and if I had no money I would accept a payment agreement. It is always good to tell the truth, since not saying anything would not be honest on my part and would go against my principles.
ResponderBorrar1.- The situation that Matt is going through is a moral dilemma in a place, where a plate is broken, Matt and his friend are in the debate of telling about what happened or leaving without saying anything. Matt believes that the correct thing is to report the accident, and thus take responsibility for the consequences of the acts, since he says that if he were the owner of the premises he would not like them to do that to him, that they destroy his products for sale and leave
2.-Matt could talk to the manager of the place and explain what happened, that none of them broke the plate, that they either found it already broken, and thus they would demonstrate their honesty.
3.- If I found a broken plate, what I would do is go quickly to the manager or owner of the premises, notify him of what happened and explain that I was not the one who broke it, that he can verify it in the security cameras, since imagining that I was The owner would not like me not to be told about what happened
Cristian Fernando Espinosa Cevallos
ResponderBorrarMatt and Noah they went to a handicrafts store, but they didn’t realized that the store was expensive, when they get to the store and they were looking for something, Matt took a plate and he broke it, Matt realized about what happened and was thinking in paid for the plate, but Matt doesn’t has enough money to pay the very expensive plate, So Noah said he is going to leave it, like nothing happened.
If Matt paid for the plate, it would be very expensive, but the dilemma is what happened, If Matt broke the plate or if the plate was already broke, if Matt didn’t pay for the plate, he is going to feel really sad about himself, In my opinion, what Matt should do is that Matt go to the manager and talk about the situation, And telling to the manager what happened, So what would happen, can be that Matt is going to pay a percent of the real price or the manager is going to check the cameras, and maybe he can take a decision about what happened.
If I were Matt, I would leave the plate in the place where I found it, and I’m going to call to someone to check the cameras to see what happened and they can judge, Because is not my fault and Is not my responsibility, and I can not take fault
In this story, there a honest person who is Matt. Matt found a broke thing in a store and his friend said that hide but Matt thinks in the owner and decide talk whit he for explic the situation
ResponderBorrarThis situation is complicate because if you were honest can be injured, and would pay the broken plates. But If dont nothing, you would feel bad for the owner
If I were Matt let the broken product where I find because I could be injured, for example the owner could charge the price of the product
ALVARO SEBASTIAN HERRERA ROSERO
ResponderBorrarMatt found a broken plate, and he wants to fix this situation, Noah has said that they don't have to talk about it and just throw that broken plate away. Mat thinks he has to report the situation to his boss and take the consequences because it's the right thing to do.
Matt could talk to his boss and fix the situation or maybe he should find out who broke it. He should check who was appointed to serve that table and this food and he would be able to figure out who was responsible.
If he talked about the problem, his co-workers might get angry. If he found the one responsible he could try to talk and repair the damage without talking to his boss, this way it wouldn't be a big problem.